Why Scholars Differ · Level 11 · ages 15–18

The Manners of Differing

How the Companions held together, spoke gently and kept their brotherhood when they differed, and what we can learn from it. No school of law is compared.

Holding Together

  1. Hold Together

    Allah tells us to hold firmly to His rope all together and not become divided: a small detail is never a reason to split.

  2. "Disagreement Is Evil"

    Ibn Mas'ud was sad about how 'Uthman prayed at Mina; when asked why he himself prayed four, he said: disagreement and division are evil.

  3. "Both of You Have Done Well"

    Ibn Mas'ud and 'Umar each met a person who recited an ayah differently; the Prophet ﷺ told them both, "do not differ".

Manners When We Differ

  1. When the Best of People Raised Their Voices

    Abu Bakr and 'Umar disagreed until their voices rose; Allah sent down a reminder, and manners came back at once.

  2. No Labels, No Mocking

    A Muslim never calls another Muslim names because of a different view; a heavy label can fall back on the one who says it.

  3. Make It Easy, Work Together

    The Prophet ﷺ sent Mu'adh and Abu Musa to Yemen: make it easy, give good news, work together, and do not differ.