Why Scholars Differ
Differing with respect
For ages 15 to 17. Your child learns why trustworthy scholars sometimes give different answers to the same question: what the Qur'an and Sunnah settle for everyone, where there is room for honest differences, and how the Companions and the great imams handled them. Level by level they learn the manners of differing, how to speak and act with people who follow another view, and how to keep the ummah together. No madhhab is promoted; only the Qur'an and authentic hadith are used, each with its source. Short ayat and hadith are memorised. It comes after the Knowing Allah block, in term 3 of each school year, one lesson a week, inside the usual weekly number.
Levels
- Level 10 · ages 15–18The Agreed Core and the Small DifferencesWhat is settled and what is open, how two sincere people can understand one text in two ways, the hadith that had not reached them, the reward of striving, and why this school teaches one simple way.
- Level 11 · ages 15–18The Manners of DifferingHow the Companions held together, spoke gently and kept their brotherhood when they differed, and what we can learn from it. No school of law is compared.
- Level 12 · ages 15–18Living With DifferenceHow to live with differences between Muslims: pray behind any Muslim imam, ask the people of knowledge, tell a detail from a new religion, put brothers first, speak what is best online, and use it all in real life.