Why Scholars Differ · Level 10 · ages 15–18
The Agreed Core and the Small Differences
What is settled and what is open, how two sincere people can understand one text in two ways, the hadith that had not reached them, the reward of striving, and why this school teaches one simple way.
The Core and the Details
One Religion, a Big Agreed Core
Most of the religion is agreed by all Muslims; only some details differ. What Allah and His Messenger have decided is not open to "my opinion".
One Instruction, Two Understandings
'Asr and Banu Qurayzah: two groups understood one instruction in two ways, and the Prophet ﷺ blamed neither. When we disagree, we go back to Allah and the Messenger.
Two Men and the Water
Two travellers prayed with tayammum and then found water in time: the Prophet ﷺ had a good word for each. 'Amr ibn al-'As on a freezing night. Allah asks of us what we are able.
Knowledge, Effort and One Simple Way
The Hadith That Had Not Reached Them
'Umar and the plague: even the greatest Companions did not know every hadith, and when one reached them, they followed it.
Two Rewards or One
A judge who strives and is right has two rewards; if he strives and is wrong, one. This is for people of knowledge, so we respect scholars and do not make up rulings ourselves.
Why This School Teaches One Simple Way
The Prophet ﷺ took the easier of two choices if it was not a sin. This school teaches one authentic, simple way so you can practise now; other Muslims do some small details differently, also from evidence.